The fee in Winter Park's new parking pilot would never apply to people who live in Winter Park, yet one of its two parks dropped out six days after the vote.
On Sept. 9, the Winter Park City Commission voted unanimously to move forward with a six-month paid-parking pilot at Lake Baldwin Park and Dinky Dock Park. The target launch is spring 2027, Bungalower reported. By Sept. 15, Lake Baldwin was out. The reason had nothing to do with what parking costs. It came down to who gets counted as a resident, and that question is the part of this program a Winter Park household will actually deal with.
The Fee Only Applies to Visitors
According to Office of Management and Budget Director Peter Moore, Winter Park residents would keep parking for free and nonresidents could pay between $2 and $3 an hour, Bungalower reported. For a household inside city limits, the hourly rate never shows up on a bill. What does show up is a new step. To get free parking, residents would need to register their vehicles.
The city has said what it wants to learn from the six months. Per Bungalower's September 14 report, the pilot is meant to show:
- who is using the parks
- how pricing affects demand
- whether the registration and payment technology works smoothly for users and staff
Two of those three goals depend on sorting residents from nonresidents correctly. Winter Park Voice added that the commission approved the pilot partly to raise money and partly to find a new way to ease parking snarls elsewhere in the city if the trial works. A registry that can tell a local car from a visiting one at the curb is the tool that would carry over to other parts of the city.
Why Lake Baldwin Couldn't Run the Test
Lake Baldwin Park, at 2000 S. Lakemont Avenue, is a 23-acre city park best known for its off-leash dog area and beach. Winter Park and Orlando both border the lake. After the vote, city staff learned about the Baldwin Park Settlement Agreement, signed in November 2002, which requires Winter Park and Orlando residents to have equal access "on the same terms" to parks owned by either city in the Lake Baldwin area, Bungalower reported. Winter Park Voice described it as covering two parks along the lake, one controlled by each city.
Under that agreement, a free-for-residents rule at Lake Baldwin would also have to cover Orlando residents. City Manager Randy Knight explained the problem in the city's September 15 announcement:
"If the pilot program went forward at Lake Baldwin Park, Orlando residents would need to be exempted from the parking fee the same as Winter Park residents, which administratively would be a larger undertaking."
At Lake Baldwin, then, "resident" would have meant someone from either of two cities, and the city would have had to exempt Orlando residents from the fee as well. That is a different program from the one the commission approved. The plan also drew a strong reaction from park users once it became public, including comments on Bungalower's social channels questioning why Orlando residents would pay while Winter Park residents parked free. The city cited that reaction along with the agreement when it made the change.
Dinky Dock Is Where Winter Park Can Define "Resident" Alone
The pilot now runs only at Dinky Dock. Knight said the technology behind it "is still important to explore as a tool to manage parking more effectively," according to Winter Park Voice. The remaining park is much smaller and far busier on weekends.
| Lake Baldwin Park | Dinky Dock Park | |
|---|---|---|
| Size | 23 acres | 1.56 acres |
| Known for | Off-leash dog area and beach | Swimming area, fishing pier, boat ramp |
| Water | Lake Baldwin, shared with Orlando | Lake Virginia, near Rollins College |
| Who counts as a resident | Winter Park and Orlando, under the 2002 agreement | Winter Park |
| Pilot status | Removed Sept. 15 | Still moving forward |
The city's park page lists Dinky Dock on Ollie Avenue, open 8 a.m. to dusk, with swimming permitted. Winter Park Voice reported that the dock is often busy on weekends, when people from surrounding cities use it to launch jet skis and other watercraft onto Lake Virginia. On a lot that size, the cars that fill it on a Saturday are the cars the pilot is trying to count.
Parking is already tight there. On the city's boating page, launch and trailer parking at Dinky Dock are first-come, first-served, and boaters have to find parking elsewhere when the trailer spaces are full. City staff also picked the original two sites partly because they believed paid parking could be tested there without pushing as many cars onto nearby neighborhood streets. For anyone living near Ollie Avenue, that spillover is what to watch once the pilot starts.
What Registration Could Ask of a Resident
The city hasn't built the registration process yet. Here is what's known so far and what's still open:
- Proof of residency. Moore said the city has used utility bills, property tax bills and driver's licenses to verify residency for other programs. The exact process for this pilot is still being worked out.
- The nonresident rate. The $2 to $3 an hour figure was a range, not a final number. As of Winter Park Voice's Sept. 15 report, the exact cost to park at Dinky Dock was still unknown.
- An annual permit. The city has talked about a yearly parking permit for nonresidents but hasn't set a price. That matters to anyone in a Winter Park household who has friends or relatives from outside the city meeting them at the dock.
- Hours, vendor and payment method. The city hasn't named a payment platform, a vendor, enforcement hours or a space count. In its statement, it described the technology as something worth exploring.
The ordinance still has to come back to the commission before the pilot can begin, and the published draft is the first place to look for how the resident step works. This post is general information about a city program and isn't legal advice. Check the final ordinance and the city's instructions for your own situation before relying on any of the details above.
Where the Ordinance Stands
City staff still have to draft the ordinance, and it has to go back to the commission before the pilot can start. The city expected the Dinky Dock draft to return in October. It wasn't on the Oct. 14 commission agenda. The next meeting on the calendar is Oct. 28, and agendas and meeting files are posted on the city's CivicClerk portal. Spring 2027 is still the target launch, with no firm start date.
Park Avenue isn't part of the plan. When Bungalower asked whether a successful pilot could lead to paid parking at other parks or public lots, including around Park Avenue, Moore said the city would first have to evaluate the results, and the city hasn't committed to expanding paid parking anywhere else. Work on the avenue is moving on its own timeline. The city marked the end of Phase 1 of the Park Avenue Refresh on Oct. 13 at Park and Garfield avenues, after repairing sidewalks and adding new streetlights and safety features, WFTV reported. Phase 2, from Garfield to New England avenues, is expected to start in January 2027.
Until the pilot launches, Dinky Dock's launch and trailer parking stays first-come, first-served, and the earliest that could change is the spring 2027 target date.
At Pamela Porazzo, we follow changes like this because the perks that come with a Winter Park address are part of what a home here offers, from free parking at the lake to how close you are to Park Avenue. If you're curious how your home's location on the Winter Park side of the line shows up in its value, request a home valuation and we'll go through it with you.